Source-led article

Apollo Economist Says AI Delivers ‘Zero Financial Payoff’ to Most Companies Outside Tech

AI News India//4 min read
A financial analyst presenting a chart that shows flat profit margins and revenue per worker for non-tech S&P 500 companies, with an AI chip icon in the background
A financial analyst presenting a chart that shows flat profit margins and revenue per worker for non-tech S&P 500 companies, with an AI chip icon in the background
Featured image from the source article

A top economist at one of the world’s largest private equity firms has published a stark assessment of artificial intelligence’s impact on corporate America: outside the technology sector, AI has delivered no measurable financial payoff.

Torsten Slok, chief economist at Apollo Global Management, released a research note examining what he calls the “S&P 493” — the S&P 500 index excluding Alphabet, Amazon, Apple, Meta, Microsoft, Nvidia and Tesla. His analysis found that profit margins and revenue per worker for these companies have remained flat, with no evidence that AI investments are translating into higher productivity.

“Despite massive investments and widespread hype around artificial intelligence, the technology has delivered zero financial payoff to corporate America outside of tech,” Slok said in the note.

The claim challenges a dominant narrative in business media and tech marketing that AI is rapidly transforming industries from healthcare to manufacturing. If correct, it suggests that the hundreds of billions of dollars spent on AI infrastructure, software licences and consulting services by non-tech firms have yet to show up in the numbers that matter most to investors and executives.

The data behind the claim

Slok’s argument rests on two key metrics: profit margins and revenue per employee. For the S&P 493, both indicators have been essentially flat since the start of the current AI investment wave. This stands in contrast to the seven tech giants excluded from the analysis, which have seen significant margin expansion and revenue growth driven partly by AI products and services.

The economist did not specify a time window for his analysis, but the note aligns with other recent studies that have questioned AI’s measurable productivity impact. A 2024 study from the MIT-IBM Watson AI Lab, for example, found that while AI can improve task-level efficiency, its effects on aggregate corporate productivity remain small and unevenly distributed.

Datos clave

Metric S&P 493 (non-tech) Big Tech (7 companies)
Profit margins Flat Rising
Revenue per worker Flat Rising
AI financial payoff Zero Positive

Why judgment matters more than calculation

Slok offered a conceptual explanation for the gap. “AI may be a great calculator, but in business, intelligence is mostly judgment,” he wrote. He argued that AI systems lack the ability to understand accountability, trust, culture, unwritten rules, ethical trade-offs or fairness — all factors that shape reputational risk and ultimately drive revenue growth and profit margins.

This framing suggests that the bottleneck is not technical capability but organisational and human factors. Even if AI can analyse data faster or generate text more fluently, it cannot replace the contextual decision-making that determines whether a business strategy succeeds or fails.

Slok appeared sceptical that this situation will change soon. He argued that it will be tough for corporate America to “turn increasingly cheap intelligence into higher revenue growth and higher profit margins.”

Implications for Indian tech and business readers

For Indian businesses and technology professionals, the Apollo analysis carries several practical implications. First, it reinforces the case for measuring AI investments against concrete financial outcomes rather than hype or adoption rates. Indian enterprises spending on AI tools for customer service, marketing automation or supply chain management should ask whether those investments are actually improving margins or revenue per employee.

Second, it highlights the gap between AI vendors and AI users. The companies that profit directly from selling AI — cloud providers, chipmakers, enterprise software firms — are the same ones excluded from Slok’s analysis. For buyers of AI, the return is less certain.

Third, the judgment-versus-calculation distinction is relevant for Indian IT services firms and startups building AI products. If Slok is right, the value lies not in building better calculators but in embedding AI into systems that respect trust, culture and ethical trade-offs — areas where Indian companies with deep domain expertise may have an advantage.

Caveats and context

Slok’s analysis has limitations. The S&P 493 includes some companies that do use AI meaningfully, and the flat aggregate metrics could mask pockets of success. The note is also a single economist’s interpretation, not a peer-reviewed study. Apollo Global Management itself, which owned TechCrunch until 2022, has significant investments in technology and AI-related assets, which may colour its public commentary.

Recent academic and industry studies have produced mixed results. A 2025 working paper from the National Bureau of Economic Research found that AI adoption in US firms is associated with modest productivity gains, but mainly in larger firms and specific tasks. Another study from Stanford’s Institute for Human-Centered AI concluded that the productivity effects of generative AI remain “uncertain and likely uneven.”

Source: TechCrunch — https://techcrunch.com/2026/10/25/ai-delivers-zero-financial-payoff-to-most-companies-according-to-apollo-economist/